The ethics of human cloning

In England, for example, the House of Lords recently voted to 92 in favor of promoting experiments which will attempt to clone human beings — even though a conglomerate of religious leaders Roman Catholics, Protestants, Jews, Muslims, and Sikhs petitioned the politicians to pause and study the ethical issues involved in such an ambitious enterprise. There are those in this country who would take us down the same road.

The ethics of human cloning

She was the first mammal to enter the world following a process of reproductive cloning, making the event a spectacular scientific breakthrough. SCNT is thus a powerful, and often effective, form of animal cloning. This provoked political and ethical debates that have never truly stopped.


Public discussion of cloning gradually receded in prominence as new issues arose to dominate the airwaves and the headlines, notably the threat of jihadist terrorism following the attacks on September 11, But issues relating to cloning technology remain crucial to debates over biomedical research and its regulation.

The announcement — with a description of the method used to bring Dolly into existence — triggered a feverish worldwide response because of the possible implications for human cloning. It was immediately obvious that SCNT could, in principle, be used to create human babies.

Across the world, many countries banned human cloning - often with significant punishments, such as lengthy jail terms, even for attempting such a thing. The case against cloning The actual arguments against human cloning are extremely varied, and I The ethics of human cloning elaborate them all here.

The Ethics of Human Cloning : Christian Courier

I go into more of them, and in far more depth, in my book, Humanity Enhanced: Genetic Choice and the Challenge for Liberal Democracies. Unfortunately, it can be very difficult to pin down precisely what any of these claims really mean in the context of bioethical debate. Some critics fear that children created via SCNT would be subjected to unfair expectations of duplicating the talents and achievements of whoever provided their nuclear DNA.

Sometimes the critics speak in terms of the autonomy of the child being violated, diminished or denied, although it can be very difficult to spell out exactly what this amounts to.

Cloning is where a cell is taken from an animal or human and the nucleus is combined with an unfertilised egg from which the nucleus has been removed, in order to create an egg which starts to divide to create (if it survives implantation in the womb) an identical twin of . This member Advisory Committee on Human Cloning convened five public meetings, each focusing on a particular aspect of human cloning: e.g., reproductive cloning, and cloning technology and stem cells. The committee is drafting a report to the legislature that is due on December 31, Menu Ethics and morality. A very brief overview of all aspects of morality: When many people see the word "morality," their first thought often relates to sexual activity of some individuals and groups, like us, use much broader definitions.

Some critics worry about a larger social effect, or even an effect on our species, if cloning restricted the diversity of children being born perhaps because parents and doctors might look for donors with a narrow range of characteristics, such as possessing high intelligence and meeting certain standards of physical beauty.

On one version of the approach, this would, in turn, set us upon a path to unequivocally horrible social outcomes. Thus cloning supposedly confronts us with a slippery slope to another slippery slope … which seems like a tenuous style of argument.

The case against cloning

Though some of these fears may have an element of truth, they are all exaggerated. To some extent, however, all of this is moot. Over the past twenty years, we have enjoyed success in cloning many mammalian species, but no one has cloned a human being. Indeed, we have been frustrated in efforts to clone other primates such as apes and monkeys.

Even if we did conceive a human embryo through SCNT, and we then managed to bring it to term, the odds are very high that the result would be a seriously deformed child.

The ethics of human cloning

Nor is it what SCNT research is really about from the point of view of reputable medical researchers. Allow me to explain. Although some ethical issues are raised with therapeutic cloning — including a concern that the associated research destroys human embryos — the idea has been obtaining legal acceptance in some countries, usually subject to tight government regulation.

If we start to see impressive results from therapeutic cloning, with new therapies emerging from the research, I expect that it will eventually obtain the same wide acceptance that IVF — in vitro fertilization — now enjoys in Western countries. However, the early debate was very one-sided.

The initial response to the dramatic Nature article by Wilmut et al. Since then, the fear-mongering has partly died down, but not before a great deal of draconian legislation was enacted across the world.

Ethics of cloning - Wikipedia

Little chance was given for calmer voices - or any dissenting voices - to be heard before governments took action.In bioethics, the ethics of cloning refers to a variety of ethical positions regarding the practice and possibilities of cloning, especially human many of these views are religious in origin, some of the questions raised by cloning are faced by secular perspectives as well.

Perspectives on human cloning are theoretical, as human therapeutic and reproductive cloning are not. In addition to the obvious risks to the first child, noted below, those who oppose human cloning point to the repugnance of a style of reproduction with such profound potential for vanity, arguing that the freedom of children and nature of the family are in danger.

PROTECTING HUMAN RESEARCH SUBJECT The MREC reviews all research using human subjects conducted by researchers of Ministry of Health or other research using facilities of . This member Advisory Committee on Human Cloning convened five public meetings, each focusing on a particular aspect of human cloning: e.g., reproductive cloning, and cloning technology and stem cells.

The committee is drafting a report to the legislature that is due on December 31, This slim volume is the best introduction to the ethical debate over human cloning now available, as two of America's most respected public intellectuals tangle over the question of whether it's a good idea to let people make genetic duplicates of themselves.

“In the future, genetic manipulation of embryos is expected to have the potential to go beyond the treatment of diseases to improvements: children who are taller, more athletic, and have higher IQs.

ActionBioscience - promoting bioscience literacy